An examination of the egalitarian theory of justice on the example of health care

Life and Work Rawls was born and raised in Baltimore, Maryland.

An examination of the egalitarian theory of justice on the example of health care

This note describes on what basis medical resources might be distributed "fairly" using, 1 a utilitarian justice approach, 2 a libertarian justice approach, and 3 an egalitarian justice approach. It is in justice that the ordering of society is centered. Aristotle BC - BC Justice is the basic principle that deals with fairness and equitable entitlement in the distribution of resources, goods and services.

Distributive justice is concerned with deciding who gets what resources when those resources are limited or scarce. The notion of distributive justice figures prominently in the allocation of health care resources, which are almost always scarce to some degree.

Concern for medical social justice is one of the three fundamental principles of the American College of Physicians http: Principle of primacy of patient welfare. This principle is based on a dedication to serving the interest of the patient.

Altruism contributes to the trust that is central to the physician—patient relationship.

Conceptualizing and Measuring Access to Care

Market forces, societal pressures, and administrative exigencies must not compromise this principle. Principle of patient autonomy. Physicians must have respect for patient autonomy. Physicians must be honest with their patients and empower them to make informed decisions about their treatment.

Principle of social justice. The medical profession must promote justice in the health care system, including the fair distribution of health care resources. Physicians should work actively to eliminate discrimination in health care, whether based on race, gender, socioeconomic status, ethnicity, religion, or any other social category.

Three theories or models of distributive justice in the allocation of health care have been described. Utilitarian Model In the Utilitarian model, goods and services are provided to those who are likely to benefit the most. This notion may be viewed either in terms of medical utility who is most likely to obtain clinical benefit?

In the medical utility model, justice refers simply to the principle of utility, broadly applied to medical procedures. For instance, attempts at quantifying the utility of a medical procedure may developed be in terms of Quality Adjusted Life Years QALY or other measure associated with a particular medical intervention in a particular patient.

Some medical utilitarians hold up the Oregon Health Plan OHP as a particularly good example of a utilitarian public health care policy.

GET REASON MAGAZINE

The Oregon Health Plan rations public medical resources by a system of prioritizing funding for health care. This is done through a process of systematically ranking publicly offered medical services, an approach that has drawn substantial international interest as a rational model of medical resource allocation.

InOregon enacted legislation to provide basic health care to all residents on Oregon Medicaid, their public health care system. This required that services be prioritized to determine what would or would not be covered — effectively establishing a rationing plan.

The final product was a priority list of condition-treatment pairs in ranked order.

An examination of the egalitarian theory of justice on the example of health care

Based on the available state funds, a line was drawn on the list - any treatment above the line was covered; any treatment below the line was not. This turned out to be at the th condition-treatment pair.

John Rawls (b. , d. ) was an American political philosopher in the liberal tradition. His theory of justice as fairness describes a society of free citizens holding equal basic rights and cooperating within an egalitarian economic system. His theory of political liberalism delineates the legitimate use of political power in a democracy, and envisions how civic unity might endure. Health Care Policy, Distributive Justice, Capability Approach, Health Care Ethics 'The Kids Are Alright': Political Liberalism, Leisure Time, and Childhood Interest in the nature and importance of 'childhood goods' recently has emerged within philosophy. Bioethics is specifically concerned with moral principles and decisions in the context of medical practice, policy, and research. Rawls’s Theory of Justice. Natural law ethics. Virtue ethics. Care ethics. Bioethical example: health care. The implication of Rawls .

Libertarian Model Libertarianism holds that the government should only regulate against force or fraud. Other than that, libertarians hold, the state should not be involved in our lives. In the libertarian model we are entitled to no more than minimal protection by the state i.

Under libertarianism the state is not permitted to raise revenue for anything more than minimal protective services. There should be no social services from the government. There should be no redistribution of wealth.

As a result, taxes will be minimal. On the other hand, individuals will have to pay for almost all services needed, including education and health care.

Libertarianism also holds that provided we acquire and transfer our assets and holdings without the use of force or coercion, justice requires that we are entitled to choose freely what to do with our belongings.

Thus, a just distribution of resources is whatever happens to result from these free-market exchanges.The aim in this essay is to bring recent political philosophical discussions of responsibility in egalitarian and luck egalitarian theory to bear on issues of social inequality in health.

We will consider how personal responsibility affects the question of when social inequalities in health are unjust. In a recent book Shlomi Segall has. Oldest and most durable theory of ethics. Virtue: definition. JUSTICE OF HEALTH CARE SYSTEM. What are the two criteria for evaluating a health care system?

Justice Medical Ethics Exam 1 Readings. 54 terms.

Egalitarian Access to Health Care as a Prerequisite for Justice | Healthcare Administration

Anatomy Exam 4: Hip and Knee Joints. . An Examination of the Egalitarian Theory of Justice on the Example of Health Care PAGES 2. WORDS View Full Essay. More essays like this: health care, egalitarian justice theory, norman daniel.

John Rawls (Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy)

Not sure what I'd do without @Kibin - Alfredo Alvarez, student @ Miami University. An egalitarian theory of justice might give us a reason to be concerned with a specific area, but applying an egalitarian principle of justice to health is only possible inasmuch as other components of well-being can be distributed equally at all times, which is implausible.

Health Care Policy, Distributive Justice, Capability Approach, Health Care Ethics 'The Kids Are Alright': Political Liberalism, Leisure Time, and Childhood Interest in the nature and importance of 'childhood goods' recently has emerged within philosophy.

Another, also contained in the preface, is Hayek's assertion that he and John Rawl's, famous for his egalitarian Theory of Justice, agree on "the essential point." More on this later. More on this.

John Rawls (Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy)